Sunday, October 23, 2016

Moving the Goal Posts

Moving the goal posts is a logical fallacy wherein one side "changes the rules" mid-discussion. This can take the form of one side demanding higher and higher standards of proof, or of changing definitions as their positions are debunked. An example of this involves two roommates, Cain & Abel. Cain maintains that he does more of the household tasks than Abel does, and that Abel should do more. Abel disagrees and requests that Cain put together a spreadsheet showing all the household chores, who does them and how much time it takes; if the spreadsheet shows that Cain spends more time doing household duties than Abel, then Abel will adjust. Two days later, Cain presents his spreadsheet to Abel. It clearly shows that Cain does 62% of all the housework. Abel points out that he works longer hours than Cain, 50 hours/week to Cain's 35, and that mowing the lawn is a more physically demanding task than washing the dishes, and cites this as a reason not to adjust. Abel has moved the goalposts, i.e. he has changed what they were measuring after they had agreed what would be measured. Another example is personal - I was participating in a forum of ex-members of a religious group. I was taking the position in a discussion that Christianity could not be demonstrated to be more "true" than any other religion. One of my fellow posters suggested that Christianity had stood the test of time - over 2000 years and counting - and that's what showed that God was behind it. I pointed out that Judaism, Buddhism, Hinduism had all predated Christianity, and if we were going to use longevity as proof of truth, then Hinduism would be the winner. My fellow poster quickly dropped the longevity argument. She had changed the standard mid-discussion. I have run into this pretty regularly in my political discussions this election cycle.

I've encountered goal post moving fairly regularly during the election season. I've probably even done it a time or two myself! You might be in the middle of talking about Trump's immigration policies and point out that we actually do need to get better control over our borders, and that Trump is correct that as a sovereign nation we should not allow illegal immigration. The goalpost is: the premise that the United States need to control its borders. Any arguments should be restricted to whether that premise is correct or not. Someone else responds with "Yeah, but Trump's a bigot and he only wants to do this because he hates Mexicans, remember, he called them rapists. Do you see where the goal posts just moved? The argument isn't now about whether controlling the border is a good thing or a bad thing, it just became about whether Trump's policy is bad because he's a bigot. Okay, it's arguable whether Trump's a bigot, and that might be a legitimate point if we were talking about his fitness to lead, but we're not, we're talking about a specific policy. The goal post move now changed the standard for evaluating Trump's plan from "Is border control a good thing" to "Is border control advocated by a bigot a good thing".

A goal post move that pre-dated the election was the so-called "birther movement". Donald Trump and others speculated that Barack Obama might not have been born in the United States. The goal post was seeing a birth certificate proving that he was. When the birth certificate was produced, the goal post was moved to "we need to see he long form birth certificate". When that was produced many still didn't believe that it was genuine; those goal posts are turbocharged.

"Moving the Goal Posts" is just one logical fallacy that politicians and those who support them use in rationalizing their own positions.

Demonizing the Opposition

Rather than have an actual, substantive discussion about the relative qualifications of different governing philosophies, most people find it easier to characterize the "other side" as in some way evil. Sometimes they even use the actual word "evil", but more often than not some euphemism is applied. The other guys "hate America", or are racists, or are crooks. Name-calling is so much easier than taking the time and energy to understand the other side's position, to understand why they believe the way that they do, and to understand why they don't agree with you. Why do people seem to at times vote against what you think are there best interests? Why do people tolerate in their own preferred candidate things that they abhor in the other candidate? There's no easy answer to this; it takes work, it takes thinking, dare I say that it takes empathy to put yourself in another's shoes, in that person's head. 

And I'm not just talking about person-to-person attacks, when you characterize a politician as, for example, a hater-of-America, you are by extension painting anyone who agrees with or supports that politician with the same brush. Statements like that just kill civil discussion right off the bat. There are people that I get along with fairly well, who can't talk about "liberals" without unmistakable disgust and accusations that we are destroying America.

The current Presidential election has just made things worse. Previous modern elections have involved serious and fundamental differences in vision for the future of the country, and there has been no shortage of ad hominem attacks, but the salvos fired by the campaigns of the major party candidates resemble the comments on Facebook, and they are often literally just that, considering the Twitter war that one of the candidates continually wages.

The root of some of this incivility can be traced partially to the rise of certain political talk radio personalities in the nineties, for example, Rush Limbaugh. The constant drumbeat of attacks against Bill Clinton gave conservatives some source material for their anger and challenged liberals to come up with counterattacks. The rise of and widespread use of social media allowed everyone to be able to publicly voice an opinion and we saw "sources" multiply like mushrooms on a rainy day. Facilitating political discussion while at the same time separating real face-to-face discussion made it very easy for people to always be in "insult mode".

I doubt that we'll see civility reign any time soon. I almost typed in "a return to civility", but I'm not sure whether I am allowing false nostalgia to color my perceptions. Just remember, when you're discussing political positions, you're talking about real people, not cartoon demons.


Tuesday, October 18, 2016

It's Not Paranoia If...Okay, Yes It Is

In a discussion on Facebook this morning about Candidate Trump, an acquaintance suggested that Trump was better than Clinton, and disputing my assertion that Trump doesn't know what he was talking about, opined that Trump would "get up to speed pretty quickly".

No, Trump would not get up to speed at all, let alone pretty quickly, because he believes that he already knows all that he needs to know. He doesn't listen to his advisors now, why would he listen to anyone if he were elected? I imagine a "decider" on steroids. That's not a compliment.

Trump is paranoid, hyper-sensitive to slights and extremely defensive. When he is attacked he unleashes a flurry of tweets, few of them especially coherent, defending himself and attacking his attacker. He creates "facts" out of thin air to buttress his position and consistently accuses others of what he is on record of being guilty of.

His paranoia regarding his shrinking poll numbers shows just how far off the cracker his cheese his cheese has slipped. For months he reveled in all the free air time he received, playing the media for suckers as he called ego-stroking news conferences, he cited his good standing in the polls as if popularity somehow equaled competence.  Until his poll numbers started slipping and the media began calling him on his bullshit. Of course, if he was now behind, the polls must be rigged, the election itself would be rigged and the media is colluding with Clinton. How many remember that when it looked like the Republican leadership and Ted Cruz might have an outside chance of denying him the nomination he speculated that the Republican nominating process was rigged against him?

This man is unstable.

Lying Liars Who Lie

I really try to understand the attraction of Donald Trump, I really do, but sometimes I just have to scratch my head...or smash it against a wall, when contemplating why people say that they're voting for Trump. I understand why some people don't like Hillary Clinton. For some it's philosophical, they're conservative in their political viewpoint and don't want to see a perceived liberal in the White House, a President who would appoint "liberal judges". These people sincerely believe that liberals are destroying America and see Hillary Clinton as exemplifying the liberal politician. If that's as far as they went, and claimed that Trump was bad, but at least he's nominally a Republican, so they're going to vote anti-liberal I'd get it. But then they try to justify, to further rationalize their preference for Trump by pointing out that "Hillary lies", "Hillary is deceitful", "Hillary is corrupt" as if Trump somehow is not.

I'm not going to spend the time in this particular post fact-checking all the accusations against Hillary Clinton, or voicing my opinion on their significance, but, even stipulating that the basic accusations are true and that Hillary Clinton is a basically dishonest, dissembling, deceitful human being, why, oh why does anyone think that Donald J. Trump isn't?

Donald Trump lies so often that it is often difficult to keep up. His speeches are full of made-up "facts". He lies about things that can be easily checked, he lies about things that he is on record as saying, he lies when he says that he didn't tweet something that he tweeted just days before, he lies about why he doesn't release his tax returns, he lies about his net worth, he admits lying during business deals, he lies about his opponents and their families, and on and on it goes. And then, he accuses others of lying, while he lies about them.

You want to make a political case for Trump, go ahead, there are legitimate, if shaky, points to be made, but to claim the moral high ground versus Hillary Clinton? Don't make me laugh.


Tuesday, October 11, 2016

Words Mean Things

Political contests have always been as much about style as about substance. There's a small percentage who geek out over policy positions, but the majority make their decisions based on feelings, impressions and sound bites. The majority isn't influenced by facts, and like religious devotees, will not change their minds no matter what evidence is presented to them. This is something to be sad about, but it isn't likely to change any time soon.

Another thing that will likely not change in the near future, and is likewise a sad thing, is politicians telling us what we want to hear, shading the truth and outright lying. Politicians generally will not lead, that is, will not stake out a position that they hold dearly and idealistically, the consequences be damned. People like that sometimes run for office, but seldom get elected, and if elected seldom get re-elected. Rather, our politicians attempt to determine what position will garner the greatest number of votes and financial support (not necessarily in that order) and stake out that position. It's not unusual for politicians to tailor their speeches and policies depending on who they are talking to.

This is why I am not upset or at all surprised that Clinton has said things to Wall Street executives (or is alleged to have said) that differs from what she says on the campaign trail, or that her position on the TPP has changed. I'm not worked up that Trump's position on immigration has somewhat changed over the course of the election season, or his "plan" to defeat ISIS has bounced around. This is normal, run-of-the-mill stuff. The same with a candidate doing whatever it takes to win an election. Clinton called in a lot of chips, Trump used his own chips, neither one pulled any punches. I'm okay with that.

As a Clinton supporter, I'm not irked about Trump bringing up Clinton's deleted emails, or the appearance of impropriety with The Clinton Foundation, or his spin on her record as Secretary of State, including Benghazi. It's all fair game, these are weaknesses that Clinton has and he's right to try and bring attention to them. Honestly (or, as Trump would say "believe me") I'm of the opinion that much of the mud thrown at Clinton is fabricated, blown out of proportion, or assigned meaning and significance that it does not really have.

What I have a real problem with is that we have, running for President, the most unprepared person who has run for the office in my memory, and probably in my parents' memory as well. Some will, and do, argue that what we need in Washington is an outsider, someone not tainted by politics as usual. I'm not going to debate that point, but being an elected official is a job like anything else, and there has to be some minimal level of qualification for the position.

Of all of our Presidents, most had some level of government or military experience. Herbert Hoover was Secretary of Commerce, Chester Arthur and George HW Bush held appointive office below cabinet level; all other Presidents had experience either in Congress or as a governor, or were elected immediately after military service, like Eisenhower. Even among the military men, other than Ike, only Zachary Taylor had no political experience.

While Donald Trump's abrasive and demagogic style annoys me, it is his utter lack of understanding of how government works, including what a President actually does that bothers me. He shows no knowledge or even curiosity about international affairs, economics or even about the way people in this country live. Unlike the usual politician, who "clarifies" a position when it causes consternation among the electorate, or apologizes and moves on, at least acknowledging a realization that the wrong thing was said, Trump often denies that he said something that he is on the record as saying. He makes baseless accusations without even a shred of evidence (remember Ted Cruz's father being accused of colluding with Lee Harvey Oswald?), and when it is pointed out that there is no evidence, or his allegation has been debunked, he just repeats it louder and more often. It's not that I disagree with him, it's just that he makes no sense. 

His attacks and insults on multiple segments of our society, his vicious attacks on his kinda, sorta allies in his own party, the gratuitous insults to anyone who disagrees with or opposes him, should worry all of us. And then there's his promise, if elected, to instruct the Attorney General to "look into [Clinton's] situation"; bellowing that she should be in jail. He is dangerous in his ignorance.

Trump appeals to much that is deplorable in our country. He has whipped up paranoia among a segment of our people with his cries to jail his opponent, to ban immigrants based on religion, and his allegations that the system is rigged and that the media is in Clinton's pocket. A crowd cheered at a woman's suggestion at a Mike Pence appearance that if Clinton is elected, we stage a "revolution" to prevent her taking office. The bigots and the ignorant among us have been given a safe place to express their bigotry. I'm not saying, like Clinton did, that half his supporters are a "basket of deplorables", in fact, the Trump supporters that I know, friends and family are pretty upstanding, good and decent people. But when I see video of Trump rallies where people are  shouting out racial slurs, screaming to lynch the opposition, including the opposing candidate, using violence against protesters; when white nationalist and racist groups support him, I can't argue that he is appealing to that which is deplorable and shameful in this nation.

Fortunately, it looks less and less likely that Trump will win this election in four weeks. It might be easy to shrug it off and, if a Republican, look to 2020, but the genie is out of the bottle.

Sunday, September 11, 2016

Whether or Not You Like His Politics, Trump is Unfit to Be President

For those who support Donald Trump there are a variety of reasons for that support. In my opinion, most of those reasons are pretty tenuous. The only one that comes close to making any sense is the lesser-of-two-evils rationale. For those who believe that a liberal Democratic agenda is bad for our country, voting for Trump might seem like the better option. But even from that point of view, Trump is no conservative. If you are voting for Trump and are a conservative, you are holding your nose and simply voting for anyone who is on the Republican ticket. I understand the position that you're in. My own disgust with the way the Republicans, not only in Congress but also at the local level, have conducted themselves over the last eight years would make it impossible for me to vote for any Republican, for any office. Sure, there's the Libertarian Party candidate, but we all know that the way our system is currently set up, a candidate from any party other than the Republicans or the Democrats has no chance of winning a national election. Libertarians, despite their congruence with conservatives on many economic issues, are on the opposite side of the fence on most social issues, like marijuana legalization. A conservative who wants Clinton to lose will not cast a so-called wasted vote for Johnson, just as a Democrat uncomfortable with Clinton would think twice about voting for Green party candidate Jill Stein. I sympathize with the dilemma that you're in.

But, Donald Trump, aside from political considerations, is unfit on many levels to be president. One problem is that he just doesn't know what he's talking about. His speeches indicate a basic and fundamental lack of understanding regarding how government works. I'm not talking about the back scratching and quids pro quo, the vote trading, and the back room deals that often are part of politics, no I'm referring to the basics of what the constitution says about separation of powers, the restrictions on what a president can accomplish, how laws are made, the relationship between the president and the military, the realities of international diplomacy, global economics...well - everything. One could argue that a president doesn't have to be an expert in everything - that's what advisors are for.  But Trump has a track record of not listening to his advisors, and no matter who is advising, the president, as President George W. Bush said, is "the decider".

Another issue is his temperament. Trump has demonstrated a proclivity toward attacking his opponents. Sure, politicians do that all the time, don't they? But Trump attacks and insults, not just political opponents, but news organizations, talk show hosts, Republicans that don't support him, and he does it in a style reminiscent of schoolyard bullying. Would his notoriously thin skin be an asset in delicate situations that require a cool head? You tell me.

Then there's the lying. The narrative has long been that Clinton is dishonest, untrustworthy and a serial liar. Where accusations against her are generally based on feelings, Trump seemingly cannot open his mouth without lying about something. And when he gets caught in a lie he just repeats it, louder and more aggressively. I know that lying is not something that's rare in a politician, and I don't expect elected officials to be angels, but the frequency and breadth of the lies is staggering.

Finally, does anyone think, that in any category, Trump will follow through on anything that he says if it is inconvenient for him? He says what people want to hear, without any consideration of how it can be done. He appeals to fear and hatred and knows how to push the right emotional buttons, but does anyone really think that he would make a good president?




Yeah, I've Considered the Accusations

One of the things that I hear from time to time on the internet and in face-to-face conversations is that we (you know, "libtards", "Hillbots", "lefties") don't care about the accusations made about Hillary Clinton, or refuse to consider them. On the contrary, what I don't do is accept everything that is thrown at her at face value, without question, what I do is attempt to ascertain the facts whenever possible, to see if there is anything to the accusation. First I look at the accusation itself, is it something that I should care about? We're electing a President, not a church pastor or a Boy Scout leader. Frankly, whether the President of the United States has personal ethics or morality that lines up with mine is really irrelevant to whether they do a decent job leading our nation. Few would argue that President Carter was a fundamentally decent man, but most would agree that he was, at best, ineffective as President. Next, does a particular trait put a candidate outside the norm? For instance, Clinton is widely accused of being a serial liar (although few actual examples can be found) - does anyone truly think that politicians don't lie, at least occasionally? Is the standard being applied to one candidate being universally applied?  Finally, are the accusations actually true? This last one is a little tougher and takes some work, rather than simply relying on internet memes, sound bites, or tweets.

In looking at Secretary Clinton's situation we see the "Where there's smoke there's fire" fallacy. Surely with so many things popping up, it all must be true. But why haven't any of the charges stuck? What about the never-ending Benghazi hearings that produced no evidence of wrongdoing despite admittedly being a tool by the Republicans to discredit her? What about the FBI investigation into the use of the private email server that resulted in no charges being filed? What about the allegations that  the Clinton Foundation gave government access to those who donated large sums of money? None of these allegations went anywhere. Anti-Clinton partisans believe that the lack of any criminal charges shows how untouchable the Clintons are and can get away with any and all illegal activity. Think about that for a minute - Clinton is so powerful that she can deflect any consequences for her actions, but not powerful enough to be able to quash the allegations themselves. Perhaps the explanation is that there's little to nothing there, but opponents just throw as much mud as they can, hoping that something sticks.

So what are the main allegations?

The private email server:
The basic facts are indisputable. Clinton used a private email account, housed on a server located in her home for email correspondence rather than a State Department email account. The big issue here is how you interpret this. Opponents will argue that this put us at risk due to classified security information being hacked. But it wasn't. Lost in all this is the fact that previous Secretaries of State (and surely other cabinet officers) did this as well. Colin Powell is on record as describing how he purposely circumvented security protocols. The FBI Director characterized this as careless. Clinton admits that it was a bad idea and would not do it again knowing what she knows now. An incident of bad judgement, but hardly rising to the level of treason or criminal activity as the "lock her up" crowd believes.

Benghazi:
The reason that anyone even knows about the private email server is the Benghazi hearings. Yes, four people, including the ambassador, were killed during an attack on our embassy in Libya. As terrible as this was, people have been killed in embassy attacks before. Despite multiple Congressional hearings by Republicans whose stated goal was to bring Clinton down, it was determined that no wrongdoing could be laid at Clinton's feet. 

The Clinton Foundation:
The Foundation takes in donations from around the world. The Clintons have been accused of favoring nations that have donated large sums to the foundation, so called pay for play. Plenty of insinuations, but no evidence. At all. Neither Secretary Clinton nor former President Clinton take any salary nor profit personally. 

Clinton cannot be trusted (she lies):
Clinton has been characterized as untrustworthy and dishonest for years. It was only recently that an example could be provided. Clinton had stated on several occasions that she had not sent any classified material through her private email server. FBI Director Comey was asked in a Congressional hearing if the mails contained classified material and had to answer that there were. This was pounced upon by the Republicans and many media outlets as proof that Clinton was lying. What was overlooked was nuance that Comey's answers actually contained. He testified that the emails were not properly marked and a person who’s an “expert at what’s classified and what’s not classified” would reasonably infer “that those three documents were not classified.” So, no, she did not lie. 

Granted, I would have liked to see a candidate who did not have the baggage that Clinton has so that we could focus on the issues, rather than the scandal du jour, but we don't have those other hypothetical candidates. Joe Biden chose not to run, O'Malley dropped out and Sanders did not get enough primary support to beat Clinton. So Clinton is who we have. In my opinion the accusations hurled at her are political, and contain as much fact as any partisan attack, but do not preclude her from being fit to be president of the United States.