Saturday, September 17, 2011

September 17, 2011

Normally I do a pretty good job of shielding myself from the ambient emotional emanations. You grow up in one of the world's biggest cities and you instinctively keep other people's thoughts and moods out of your head. But when millions of people are all focusing on one single sad and tragic event, the blue vibes become hard to resist.

Last week marked the tenth anniversary of the 9/11 attacks and the air was full of ghosts.

On September 12th I was asked where I was and what I was doing on 9/11 and despite having related it here in this blog, I was vaguely offended at having been asked. The person who asked was not someone who I have a close relationship with, or even like. After swishing it around in my mind for a while I think the best way that I can articulate it is that in talking about horrific events, we get to decide how and when we talk about them and should not be quizzed in order to satisfy an idle curiosity.

In this era of online disclosure of our every passing thought, there still needs to be some decorum, some respect, some boundaries.

Saturday, September 10, 2011

September 11, 2001

I woke up on September 11, 2001 with a severe hangover. In less than two months I would find myself thrown out of my home and things weren't going well at all. Rather than interact with a woman who would do nothing but criticize and find fault, my routine on the evening before my day off was to rent several videos, buy a six pack or two of Leinenkugel and stay up all night drinking and watching mindless entertainment. When I stumbled into the living room that awful Tuesday morning I found my children watching CNN - one of them quickly told me that a plane had crashed into the World Trade Center. My first thought was that a small private plane had clipped one of the towers. The news reports were confused and the images unclear. But it quickly became evident that a full-sized jet airliner had plowed into one of the Twin Towers. While I sat trying to make sense of it all, while we watched the coverage, the second plane hit and the chaos multiplied. The day only got worse.

The Twin Towers of the World Trade Center were an image that I grew up with. From the third floor of St. Pius X, my elementary school in Rosedale, Queens, we could see the towers being erected 20 miles away. Visits to Manhattan frequently included a jaunt to the top and the view of an endless horizon. For several years I worked summer jobs and later a full time gig in New York's financial district literally in the shadow of the towers. On one occasion, while employed as a mail room boy, I ran out with my co-workers to see a man walking a tightrope between the two. They were a duo of hulking, yet elegant, giants, always looking over my shoulder, always a part of the skyline; we grew up together, the towers and me.

On September 11, 2001 I quickly was assured that none of my family or friends were killed or injured. My brother, New York City Police officer and my cousin, a New York firefighter were nowhere near the devastation, none of the family lived or worked in Manhattan. Despite this, I felt a certain helplessness, a sense of being set adrift as the city that I always have considered my home was so mercilessly attacked. Nine months later during a visit to family I had to pull my car onto the shoulder to weep as I saw the gaping hole in the skyline.

Ten years later...the world, our world will never be the same

Tuesday, September 6, 2011

Ethics

Although most people don't want to admit it, ethics are a personal thing, a line which has on one side that which is acceptable and on the other that which is unacceptable. Perhaps you read the first sentence and wonder why I believe that "most people don't want to admit it". Mainly because for most people ethics is not strictly personal, but is taken wholesale from a book. At least that's what they say, while at the same time abiding by their own personal code. In my view, those who say plainly that their ethics are personal are more truthful, or at least aren't deceiving themselves. Now those who claim to follow holy book ethics and actually do it are equally truthful, but my observation has been that most people claim one set of ethics and even judge society by that set, while in reality holding to a completely different ethical set.

A good (if exaggerated) example of this is the movie gangster. Oftentimes the mafioso claim to be Catholics, attend mass, and have religious icons around their homes, yet their lives revolve around crime. Even beyond the egregious example of crime, loyalty and respect are the rules by which they live, not the holy book on the coffee table. Even beyond the fringe and the fictional, how many Christians live by the pacifistic turn the other cheek, love your neighbor ethos of Jesus? Instead, how many of them are actually living by their own framework of right and wrong while paying lip service to Christian ethics.

So what happens when one set of ethics are espoused and another set are acted upon? One result might be guilt. An individual takes action that is in the best interests of their family, nation, business etc but that action is proscribed by their chosen holy book, so they feel bad about it.

Another direction might be the path of absolution. If your deity is one of the more forgiving ones, any action contravening said deity's commandments will be forgiven, so act out with impunity and you'll be welcomed back into the fold. Or you can take solace in your belief that all men are frail and fall short of divine expectations and resign yourself to failure...once again hiding behind absolution.

Why not take an honest, analytic look at the circumstances of life and craft your own ethics? If you going to live by a set of rules, why not a set of rules of your own devising that fit into your own culture, your own uniqueness? Some might say that this would be playing God? That we have no right to set up our own set of rules in competition with those set up by an all-knowing creator. I would answer that if you're not following these rules but looking for loopholes and detours around them, you are doing the same thing. But the greater issue is to question whether these rules have indeed been handed down by a deity at all.

Wednesday, August 17, 2011

Family

"But you're too cool to have been in a cult" my good friend Pam said to me one afternoon in the cool darkness of O'Rourke's Tavern. Nice thought, but no, I'm not too cool to have been in a cult. (Some of you who know me really well might say that I'm not cool either, but that's another essay now isn't it?) - I'll spare you the details, at least for today, but about ten years ago I was was kicked out of a small insignificant group that had ruled many aspects of my life since 1978. The doctrinal and many of the practical minutia are for the most part not germane, but the founder of this group had a saying, referring to the Bible: "I have no friends when it comes to God's Word" - which, if you are a believer in a literal interpretation of the Bible doesn't sound too bad, but in this particular group, "God's Word" came to be understood as one man's spin on the Bible and by extension, an unquestioning obedience to the man himself.

One of the side effects of this teaching was that "the household", i.e. the core group of people committed to this leader and his group, was more important than anything or anyone, including friends and family. During my time in this group I saw many, many friendships and even marriages broken up due to this thinking. I saw families shattered and fragmented as a result of this insidiousness. Including my own.

Now for all of you bible fans out there, all of you who have a "personal relationship" with Jesus, I have absolutely no problem with people who take their religion seriously, and by "seriously" I mean those who make an effort to line up the talk and the walk, not those who attempt to make over every other human being in their own image. If you're going to claim that a leather bound book of sayings, letters, treatises, mythology, folk history and legends is the infallible, without error word of your god, at least put in the time to live it.

Over the years I have had the good fortune to make the acquaintance of many people who strove to live their faith, men and women who took all the good things from their "holy book" and put them into living breathing action. I'm related to many of those people. But when a fanatical ideology, even if it is a religious fanatical ideology, becomes your basis for interacting with the general public, that's bad enough; when extreme judgementalism over ones adherence to dogma is applied to family, then it just becomes hurtful.

Every family has the proverbial black sheep. If you don't know who it is in your family, then in all likelihood it's you. But we all, every single one of us do stupid things, do things that we regret, even do things that might have serious consequences. Who among us wants to be judged for all time for a period of life or even a single day, an isolated incident that we regret, that we would take back, change if we could? Then why are we so quick to do it to others? How eager are we to apply our own personal dogma to the lives of those around us, our friends, our family?

For many years I applied a dogmatic intolerance to my views and relationships with others. About ten years ago it came back to bite me in the ass as I found myself alone and living in "The Hovel" after being judged unworthy. But my family, whom I had been judgmental and intolerant to welcomed me with open arms, putting the past behind them, as if nothing untoward had happened... because that's what family does.

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Balance

Balance does not mean always walking at the perfect midpoint between two extremes, or always settling for mediocrity; balance is an average. Is the weather here in Nebraska always 100° plus? Or it it sometimes very cold? Or in-between? Doesn't the day vary from very bright at noon to pitch-black at midnight? Our lives are like that. Walking the balance could mean that some weeks you are putting your whole heart and soul into your 9-5, other times work just isn't the priority. Our health, our hobbies, our politics, our religion, our jobs, our families are all a continuum of light and dark, fast and slow, important-at-the-moment and it-can-wait. 


The challenge in living a balanced life is that sometimes there are just so many things that you want to do that there just isn't enough time for it all. Don't get so swept away and caught up in by those things that insist on our attention that the quiet whispering voices of what could be go unheard. 



Tuesday, July 5, 2011

Making a Snowball

           Howling like an unseen wolf, the wind makes its presence known, pawing at the suddenly insufficient layers of clothing, while the snowflakes paradoxically caress like the lover who is no longer there. A single tear bravely tracks its way down the stubble covered cheek and onto the brown leather jacket, congealing into just another snowflake. “Can the heart freeze like my stupid toes are starting to?” the lone figure asks himself, adding “And can my inner dialogue get any more dramatic?” Still, drama aside, it’s been a rough, raw kind of day. Rough enough that the frozen feet that the aforementioned frozen toes are attached to have walked themselves to the span of Adams Street that becomes a bridge across Interstate 180. The whir of the cars passing underneath is like steel hummingbirds while the occasional truck rumbles and shakes the asphalt and chain link as the tread of giants might. “This” he sighs, “Is a freakin’ stupid idea” and climbs down from the fence that some engineer thought was proof against drunks and jumpers. The last swig of Jack Daniels (Old #7 Tennessee Whiskey, Lem Motlow proprietor) disappears as does the bottle (into some bushes). Then, as the traffic thins and the silence grows, he bends over, squatting in the snow and begins to make a snowball. At least he knows how to do that.
            He remembers a day, decades past. running around with his brothers and sisters, ecstatic that school was cancelled, the Sisters of the Immaculate Conception having deemed the day too raw even for those hardened by rulers across knuckles; he’s bent over, squatting in the snow, muttering under his breath. “Why don’t I know how to make a stupid snowball?” he whines, the double layers of wool that wrap his feet like Brill-O pads disguised cleverly as socks keeping his feet as warm as Mom intended. He remembers getting dressed, each layer of clothes like the armor of some medieval knight, specially fitted for Arctic adventures. The green knit cap that Aunt Sissy made him for Christmas beginning to absorb some of the sweat earned by chasing his brother Mike around the yard. And suddenly there’s Dad, just home from work, tucking his service revolver into the garage, ready to join in. “So son, let’s make some snowballs” Dad growls, not letting on that he knows that his boy doesn’t have the slightest idea how to construct this simplest of snow creations.
            His dad was a city cop. Rosedale was a cop neighborhood. The city had a rule then that a cop had to live within city limits, so the neighborhoods on the border of the city, as far from the dirty, nasty center as possible and still with the city, were cop neighborhoods. Every booth at the church bazaar was manned by a guy with a gun, school kids shared the bus ride to school with men who read newspapers and carried brown bag lunches but had guns strapped to their ankles. That was his dad. He was also the guy who umpired Little League and coached his kids’ hockey team and went to church every day. His dad spent three hours a day, an hour and a half in the morning and an hour and a half in the evening commuting by bus and train. That was his dad. He was also the guy who made a point of putting his gun and badge away when he got home to spend time with his five kids.
            Even though there’s a pack of kids running around, siblings and cousins and neighbors and school pals, it’s as if there’s no one else there but father and son. Crunching snow echoes as Dad walks across the yard and picks up a handful of snow and motions for his son to do the same. Having recently graduated from colorful, hard to lose in the snow mittens, to gloves, fleece on the inside, suede on the outside, and leather on the palms, the boy holds the loosely cohering snow in his cupped hands and following along with Dad, slowly and methodically applies pressure to the not wet enough snow, pushing and pressing, smoothing and molding until Dad has a perfect ivory sphere and the boy has a lumpy mass that resembles a rogue asteroid. “Take your gloves off son” he is instructed. And miming the apparent expert motions, he uses the heat from his bare hands to slightly melt the crust of his little globe, working magic that he never thought he could until he too had a perfect ivory sphere. “Dad, I did it!” he yelled, a little embarrassed at what he thought was a girlish squeak to his voice. “It’s perfect”. Dad chuckled, “So now we need to make a hundred more so we can ambush your Uncle Richie and your cousins!”    
            Memory skipped forwards a generation to a day when he was the Dad and it was his kids running around the yard, off from school. Except that he didn’t feel like a dad, not like ‘Dad” was a dad. In a thousand ways he felt that he didn’t measure up, he didn’t have a job that defined him like his father’s did; he didn’t have the seemingly effortless ability to do the right thing, but today he was going to try.
            “The perfect ivory sphere, that’s what grandpa’s snowballs looked like” he found himself reminiscing to his son. “So, what do your snowballs look like Dad?” smirked the son. “Look, wise guy, you take those foo-foo mittens off and get some gloves on if you’re going to make snowballs”.
            Not surprisingly, his son doesn’t need as much instruction as he did at that age, and it certainly helps that the snow is wetter and easier to pack than that day when the nuns cancelled classes so that it requires very little pressure to shape the crystalline whiteness into those ivory spheres. An hour later, before each of them, a pyramid of ivory spheres, or maybe rogue asteroids, but each one hand crafted and ready to leave off being admired and put into action. The basketball hoop stood at the end of the driveway, a likely target, the garage door was also very inviting, but in the end, snowballs are meant to be thrown by their makers at other makers of snowballs. The first snowball hit him square in the face, the icy sting as stunning as the blow itself, exacerbated by the sudden fogginess that accompanies loss of glasses by the nearsighted. But revenge is cold, cold as a snowball. After an hour all the son can say to him is “Perfect ivory spheres Dad; perfect ivory spheres”, laughing as he says it.
            “Memory seems to be dragging me to snowy days it seems” he thinks, as the sights and sounds of those two days, one as the son, the student of snowball-ology, and another as the father, the teacher, faded away. “Today, now today was not so fun filled”, floated to the top of his consciousness. He could see his children’s faces as they looked out the living room window, some angry, some sad, some defiant, all confused about what was happening. She stood in front of him, a cigarette between her fingers, darting like a wasp to her lips and back to her side, punctuating her sentences with it, doing everything but extinguishing it in his eye. While she stood almost a foot shorter and a hundred pounds lighter, she seemed to tower over him, dominating, crushing with words and more. She invoked her God; she quoted from her Holy Book, her voice sing-songed like a televangelist and she intoned the list of his sins. He was cast out, cast out from their marriage and from his children. The fog from the cold and the cigarette smoke mingled together, like a veil separating him from all that he loved. He slunk away, got in his car and drove away, watching his life dwindle away in the rear view mirror.
            “Geez, how maudlin do I have to be before somebody just stamps ‘cliché’ on my forehead” he says, fully back in the present, unfolding his six foot, 240 pound frame as he stood up, holding in his hand a perfect, ivory sphere. He leans through a ragged hole in the chain link fence where he had climbed earlier and, in lieu of his previous plan, he let the snowball make the leap, watching it fall, glinting in the streetlights, turning, turning, turning, that one spot that he hadn’t quite smoothed out indicating each revolution. Time seemed to slow as his creation grew closer to the surface, but finally it hit, flattening and expanding, shattering and dissolving and it was no more. “Better you than me, snowball” he croaked and began the long walk home.
            Despite the rubber soled, fleece lined boots and two pairs of socks; there is a fuzzy numbness where his feet ought to be. Aunt Sissy’s green knit cap has survived the decades and still keeps the heat in better than any other hat he’s ever owned. Giving the frost giants a heartfelt middle finger he walks across the street to the playground, to the snow drifted basketball court where he begins to make snowballs. The snow is drier than he’d like it, but the man whom he is now finds himself more apt than the boy he once was to apply sufficient pressure, smoothing out the grooves as he readies himself to hurl his creation at the backboard; and stops. Gingerly, handling the snowball like a Fabergé egg, he sets it down and begins another, and another, depleting the snow down to the dead brown grass as his arsenal grows larger and larger. He moves over to the children’s slide and swings, scooping up handfuls of snow as if mutually assured snowball destruction awaits any who defies him. “I can do this, I can do it; this is something that I can do” he chants. Sweat begins to pour down his neck from under the knit cap and begins to soak his shirt. Even his feet begin to feel warm. The furnace of his tenacity burns fierce.
He is about spent when with a “thump!” something hits him in the face, knocking off his glasses and causing a painful iciness to take up residence where his face should be. Before he can retrieve his glasses he hears the words “Perfect ivory sphere Dad, perfect ivory sphere” and knows that he still is “Dad”. His fingers clumsy due to the thick gloves he replaces his eyewear, the world shifting from smeared watercolor to digital photograph as he does so and sees the smirking face of his son. “You didn’t think I believed all that crap, did you Dad?” he said as he hefted another snowball. “You’re the best Dad in the world…even if you’re wearing that foo-foo hat”
             
           

Monday, May 30, 2011

Some of my best friends are theists...

Just a smidgen of clarification: I have nothing against anyone's religion or god; and just to be even more clear: I'm not an atheist. The point that I am making is  manifold.

  • I question whether people would interpret unexplained, mysterious events and coincidences as evidence of the action of the god of the bible if they hadn't first been inculcated with information in the general culture about this specific subset of theism first.
  • The dominant cultural representation of religion in a nation tends to be the default position for spirituality for most people. I suspect that identical experiences in diverse cultures would yield diverse, not identical interpretations. 
  • Even within the dominant culture, independent thought still tends to conform to some extent to the cultural framework. 
What I'm against is the belief that one interpretation of experience is necessarily the correct one, much less the only one.