Audience Participation

There was an article the other day about an artist that I had never heard of flying off the handle when her audience didn't respond enthusiastically enough during a performance. In an expletive-filled tirade she stopped the song and complained loudly about the lukewarm response, referring to how much work she put into the song.

It's understandable that a singer would be upset that her work of art that she put so much time, love & energy into (although the online comments suggest maybe not so much of any of those) would be received so tepidly. I've heard musicians complain about people talking during their performances (this I understand - I go to a show to listen to music, not the loud opinionated guy on the next bar stool). On the other hand when I'm experiencing live music, I didn't sign on to become part of the entertainment.

Back in my younger days I used to attend Twisted Sister shows. There was a band that insisted on audience participation. Not only were you goaded into the expected responses, but if you happened to be quietly standing in the back, you were singled out for abuse. Not something that was all that enjoyable. I've also been at shows where the audience was lectured for clapping on 1 & 3 instead of 2 & 4 (2 & 4 is correct, right?). Okay, I get how off-beat clapping can throw a band off, but hey, I'm not the musician here!

But the truth is that there are a variety of different ways in which people express their appreciation for music. Singing the chorus when encouraged to do so, dancing, cheering, (clapping on 2 & 4), "putting your hands in the air", yelling the appropriate response when the singers asks "is everyone doin' alright?" are all traditionally acceptable. How about shutting the hell up during an acoustic or otherwise quiet song? Taking non-obtrusive photos (that's what I like to do), and sharing them with the band, buying some merch, or just thanking the band after the show for a great show. All of these things, in their own way, express admiration and appreciation for the performance.

Just like every musician is unique, and there are a variety of musical genres, every fan is a unique and there are a variety of ways to to express enthusiasm and love for music.