Sunday, September 20, 2015

Black Lives Matter

It should be evident to anyone who keeps up with the news (even if it's just on Facebook) that there has been a lot of coverage of police officers shooting (and sometimes killing) unarmed black men, often without any clear indication that they were presenting any danger whatsoever to the police. In the wake of several of these killings, the phrase "Black Lives Matter" spread throughout the media, both mainstream and social. Pretty quickly a backlash developed, with "All Lives Matter" and "Police Lives Matter" springing up in some kind of counterpoint. Assuming that you're not a bigot who is offended that the "niggers" are getting "uppity" - you really should have understood that saying that black lives matter is not a suggestion that only black lives matter, it's a reaction to the perception that, due to the seeming epidemic of unarmed black men being shot, black lives don't seem to matter. Perhaps they could have said "Black Lives Matter Too"- but they shouldn't have had to.

Offensiveness - Part II

Disclaimer: Nothing in this post is intended to be a commentary on any actual situations in the author's place of business or personal interactions, but are intended as general observations

In a previous post I discussed my view on the trend of belittling people who point out insulting language and situations or who take issue with bigoted statements in the media or general culture. I asked why it had become offensive to be offended. I've observed a tendency to make pointing out offensiveness the problem, rather than the offensiveness itself. This doesn't mean that I think that it is always warranted to be hyper-sensitive to the words and actions of others. There is indeed a balance between each of us being responsible for what we say and for the hearer to be responsible to not over-react or misinterpret. Context, tone of voice, facial expression and intent are all important. Not every ill-thought-through comment, joke, facile observation or smart-ass remark is cause for a trip to the legal compliance officer or a brawl in the backyard. So why do people quit jobs, take legal action, punch people out, change churches, engage in high-level passive-aggression, decapitate journalists and post ambiguously on Facebook?

Much of what we communicate is ambiguous; partly due to the imprecision of the English language and partly due to our own sloppiness in using the English language. There's also the tendency of people to not listen to the actual words being said (or written) and let their emotions determine not only the meaning of the words, but the actual words themselves. I'll give an real-life example:
My ex-wife and I were having an argument about something and I was asking a lot of questions that she didn't want to answer and she asked me why I was asking so many questions. I replied that I lived there and I wanted to know what was going on. (The argument probably had something to do with what our kids were up to) In recounting this conversation to someone a few days later she reported my words as "This is  my house and I'll ask the questions here", adding an aggressive tone that was not included in my original statement. 
What she did was take my words, superimpose what she thought I meant and unconsciously changed my actual words to reflect this perceived meaning. This is not unusual, we miss details of what is being said all the time and our brains fill in the missing bits, or we didn't take the time to accurately remember what was said and recreate scenarios based on what ought to have happened. Written communication has its own problems. While the issue of misremembering isn't there, neither is the mitigating effect of tone of voice, facial expression and body posture. The inherent ambiguity of our language could even be amplified in written communication.

Some of the problem arises when people just refuse to give others the benefit of the doubt, and assume an evil or hurtful intent when the words and what was behind them were innocuous. Granted, sometimes what people say is hurtful and is said with maliciousness, but I believe that malignant intent should be the supposition of last resort




Wednesday, September 9, 2015

Fighting to Make Us Free?

Oftentimes we hear praise for those who serve in the U.S. military as those who "make us" or "keep us" free; or alternately, that we "owe our freedom" to those who wear the uniform. While intending no disrespect for military veterans and active duty personnel, this is not strictly true. While I would have little argument with anyone who would say that the military has kept us safe, in what way does a military presence keep us "free"? The military is not some loosely organized posse of altruistic Americans hunting down and fighting against injustice like some comic book superheroes. The military, collectively, is an agent of the state and as such carries out the will of the elected leadership of the state. One of the functions of the military is to defend against attacks on the United States and to go on the offensive against those attackers to prevent further attacks. How many actual attacks have been made against us? Other than individual acts of terrorism (which is the bailiwick of the FBI in any case), not many. The British attack on Washington, D.C. in the War of 1812, The Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941 and the 9-11 attacks (arguably FBI territory, not military). One might add some isolated German attacks on coastal installations in World War II and the "war" with Pancho Villa in the early part of the twentieth century. One could argue that the military acts as a deterrent to attacks as well. Fair enough, preventing attacks also keeps us safe. But could any of these actions be categorized as an attempt to take away our freedom? The 9-11 attacks arguably could, but should more logically be classified as an act of terror - retaliation against our actions in the Middle East; the Pearl Harbor attacks were a preemptive strike in an ongoing war (for the Japanese). Many of our other interventions, Vietnam, Korea, the Gulf War, were in the role of "The World's Policeman" and could only be looked at as "maintaining our freedom" if one took a long, and extremely speculative view.

So what makes us free? What keeps us free? Religious people would credit their respective gods. But what people are responsible for instituting and maintaining our freedoms?

What is "freedom"? Loosely defined, it means to be in a society absent coercion or oppression, to be able to "do what you want" without outside interference. A more nuanced definition would recognize that one person's freedom of action cannot impinge on another's freedom. In other words my freedom to expand my business cannot include using my neighbor's yard to build a new storeroom. So, in reality, freedom is not anarchy. The rights and freedoms of all a society's individuals and groups must be balanced. What we as a nation consider to be the correct balance of freedoms has changed many times in our history. Early on, our definition of freedom included the freedom to take land from the original inhabitants. This was not unusual at the time; the history of the world is the story of successive waves of war and conquest and displacement of those who lost. We included the freedom to enslave others, and denied full freedom to a host of groups, including women. Later, as the industrialisation took hold, workers had no rights and business owners had the freedom to treat them as they would. Laws are written to restrict the "freedom" of people to pollute so that others may be "free" from pollution; to require certain safety rules in the workplace to that workers can be "free" from being injured at work..etc.

Who "made us free"? Who "kept us free"?

We could start with the nation's founders, the first group to break from the colonial system that had defined the world since the days of Columbus. Or we could even go back to the great minds of The Enlightenment, upon whose writing the Founders based many of their ideas. Freedom, or its loose synonym, liberty, was not a concept that was very popular prior to the 18th century. Most nations were still ruled by monarchs or oligarchies and the idea of individual rights had not caught on. The great thinkers of the American Revolution really set the tone for freedom.

We could continue with the abolitionists who fought to outlaw slavery. Despite the high-minded pronouncements in the Declaration of Independence, we not only had legal slavery, but the native people were not even considered "people" within the meaning of the law. We often hear that slaves were considered 3/5 (60%) of a person. Actually, slaves were considered 0/5 - 0% a person. The 3/5 number was only in respect to the census. Northern states did not want to count states at all while Southern states wanted to count slaves for the purpose of congressional apportionment.

How about adding environmentalists to the list. Derided as tree-huggers and environmentalist wackos, these are the people that you have to thank for clean air, clean water and (along with Teddy Roosevelt) national parks.

Early union organizers were also among those who fought to make us and keep us free. While modern-day unions are perceived as greedy and out of touch, and most unions these days represent public/government employees, employment pre-union was often dangerous and abusive. Think you work your butt off 40 hours each week? How about seven days a week, ten-twelve hours a day? How about unsafe working conditions? So much of what we take for granted now was fought for by union men and women.

What about whistle blowers and investigative journalists? The effect that a free press has in keeping politicians honest cannot be overstated. And those who have braved loss of income and blacklisting to bring government abuses out into the light of day should be recognized for their fight to ensure our freedoms as well.

And lest we think that abolition meant that freedom was achieved  for blacks, part of our freedom is owed to those who fought, and sometimes died, for civil rights regardless of color. This includes the big names like Rev. King, the revolutionaries like the Black Panthers and Malcolm X, the quiet resisters like Rosa Parks and the ordinary people who marched across bridges and were set upon by dogs and police with fire hoses. Civil rights struggles continue today - even though the Supreme Court has ruled for marriage equality, it is still legal to discriminate against people based on their sexual orientation or gender identity in most states.

There are many, including those who serve in the military, who have contributed to the safeguarding and expanding of our freedoms in this country, to all of them, we owe a debt of gratitude.


Thursday, August 13, 2015

Believing vs. Knowing

Religious believers often deride other religious believers for their beliefs. Most religious people hold their own beliefs to be "truth" while what other people believe is just "religion". I have heard people from a variety of religions insist vociferously that their religion is most definitely not a religion, but "the way of a father with his children", "a way of life" or "we don't believe, we know". People hold certain beliefs or follow certain religions for a variety of reasons: maybe it was the religion that they grew up with and saw no reason to change; maybe it was the religion of the community or culture and societal pressure made it impossible to even consider anything else, let alone change; maybe someone trusted and respected convinced you that their religion was the way to go; perhaps a traumatic or emotional event spurred belief in a specific path. Some view their religious faith as something private - nothing will convince them to discuss it; others cannot be convinced to shut up about it! What I have found to be a common thread among believers of all religions with whom I have encountered is the inability, or perhaps refusal, to discuss  or question the underlying premise of their belief. In other words - you believe in God, or fairies, or Scientology - why do you believe? What evidence has convinced you that what you believe rises above opinion and moves into the more solid realm of knowledge?

Some of the arguments for the existence of God rely on the supposition that there must have been a "first cause" or creator. There are many variations of this argument: that the complexity of the world/universe/living things indicates that it could not have happened by chance and therefore, logically, something or someone must have created it. Who would that be? Why, God, of course. Let's set aside, for a moment, all of the reasons why complexity could have resulted from mutations, random chance and billions of years of opportunities to evolve and grow. Let's stipulate, for the sake of argument, that the universe couldn't have come about by evolution, mutation or chance and that it necessarily is the product of a creator. Who or what is that creator? What are its (his, her?) attributes?

For those who accept the premise that their must have been a creator, the default identification is the dominant god of the culture. For most Americans, that would be the god of the bible, for many Hindus in India, it might be Vishnu or Shiva. Other cultures would identify different entities as the creator. For those within a given culture, it would not even occur to them that the creator might be different than the god (or goddess or pantheon for that matter) that they grew up believing in. This, when considered logically, adds another layer to the matter: assuming that there had to be a creator, which of the numerous religions and mythologies describes that creator? So, the argument from complexity or the argument from nature, if accepted, really only addresses whether or not a god or gods exist, but does not address the nature of deity.

Another argument for the existence of God is one of personal experience. This one varies widely: sometimes the experience is a miracle, sometimes it is an audible message, sometimes just a "personal relationship" or a feeling "in ones heart". Maybe it's got something to do with angels, or an "answer" to a prayer. Prayer results can actually be measured, so I will get back to that later, but feelings and messages are somewhat different. This one is a little fuzzier than the "need for a creator" argument, because generally, people are loathe to be specific about what they mean when they talk about God in their hearts, talking to God, or having a personal relationship with God. As with the "creator" premise, let's accept for the sake of the discussion that people who say that they are experiencing these things are really experiencing them. This is not the same as accepting that there is an objective, measurable phenomenon going on, but that those who are claiming to experience the presence of the divine are feeling or experiencing something that is real to them. Again, this is more difficult to address than the previous "evidence", since it is personal and subjective and those who claim it often get defensive about even being asked about it. But the question that the skeptic has is similar to the question asked of those who use  nature and its complexity as evidence: how do you know that what you are experiencing is God (or Allah, or Vishnu)? Like the previous argument for God's existence, cultural conditioning comes into play. You're going through a rough time, looking for answers, or maybe just comfort, and in your hour of deepest despair you feel like you are being enveloped in warm, unconditional love, maybe you even hear a voice confirming that you are being enveloped in warm, unconditional love. Like the previous scenario, if you are a Hindu in India, you may attribute this to Krishna, if you are a Wiccan, to the Earth Mother Goddess, if you are an American - it's probably God or Jesus. How do you know that the feeling or message that you are receiving is from the deity or entity that you think you are receiving it from? My opinion is that people have feelings or experiences that they have no scientific, rational, logical explanation for, and interpret them in light of what they already believe about the supernatural and the spiritual.

Then there are incidents where people walk away from horrific accidents, are barely missed by out of control cars, or recover from a life-threatening disease or injury. Like the other examples, believers will attribute these "miraculous" results to the god of their own upbringing or culture.

Finally, there's prayer. There's some disagreement about what prayer actually is. Some will define it as praise for God or talking to (or hearing from) God, but for the purposes of this essay, we'll define it as most people practice it: asking for something from God, whether it be healing, financial prosperity, finding lost objects or getting a good parking space. Granted, there are things that get prayed for where the result sure looks like an affirmative answer to the prayer - the resolution being so statistically unlikely that attributing it to the divine seems reasonable. The problem with saying that prayer works or using answered prayer as an indication of the existence of God is the sheer unreliability of the thing. Even people who are utterly convinced that prayer works will usually admit that sometimes they do not receive what they prayed for. Weasel words are then employed: sometimes the answer is "no", God works in mysterious ways, God gives us what we need, not necessarily what we want and on and on. If any of these rationales for non-answers to prayer are true, why bother to pray at all? The other issue is the confirmation bias of those who believe. Positive results are played up, while negative or non-results are ignored.

The bottom line for all of this is that sometimes things happen that we don't understand, that may be supernatural, but that we choose to interpret in light of what we already believe about the world. These unexplainable events may be the god of the bible, (or any other god or spirit) but objectively there's nothing to indicate that this is a surety, that our decision to believe in a certain interpretation of events indicates objective knowledge, but is anything but merely belief.










Thursday, July 16, 2015

Is Being Offended Worse Than Being Offensive?

When did it become a bad thing to be offended at something? When something is offensive, shouldn't the reasonable, rational, logical reaction be to be offended? Yet we read, all over the Internet, blogs and comments mocking people who are offended and denigrating the very idea of being offended at something. People who point out offensiveness are belittled as "butthurt" or vilified as promoting "political correctness". Should the default position for our society be "I'll say anything that I want and screw you if you don't like it"? How about we recognize that there is a difference between "I don't like or agree with what you say" and "What you're saying is hurtful and offensive"? An example of some things that I don't agree with:

  • Christianity (or the religion or philosophy of your choice) is the only true way
  • Socialized medicine would be bad for our country
  • Midwestern culture and values are the best way of life
  • Being a Nebraska Cornhuskers football fan
I disagree with all of the above, but I don't find them offensive in any way. They're just opinions. I'm not going to publicly attack you for being a member of a religious group, or espousing conservative political views or praising a regional way of life or being a sports fan. Examples of things that I find offensive:
  • "You're an evil immoral person if you don't believe the way I do"
  • "Jews, Blacks (or Whites for that matter, pick your group) are inferior or unworthy of civil rights"
  • Use of racial or ethnic slurs
  • Use of symbolism that represents racist ideas or philosophies
I find these things offensive. I believe that these kind of beliefs and points of view have no place in public discourse. I in no way advocate for people being restricted from expressing their offensive opinions, but those who promote offensive ideas should expect others not only to be offended, but to express their offense out loud. Some people will respond to expressions of offense by becoming even more offensive, ranting about how they don't care what anyone else thinks, but some will reconsider their words and see things from the other guy's point of view. 

Being offended at offensive words and actions is the correct response. 

Pointing out how expressing offensive opinions hurt real people is entirely appropriate. 

If you rail about how worthless Food Stamp recipients are I'm going to let you know that I was once a Food Stamp recipient

If you pontificate about how all morality is based on the Bible and those who don't follow it are morally bankrupt I'm going to tell you that I'm not a Christian

If you wax self-righteous about how all the illegal immigrants are criminals I might bring up the unsavory aspects of the arrival on these shores of at least one of my ancestors

I'm going to ask you to think

Do you want to see fewer people being offended? Stop being so damn offensive


Thursday, July 9, 2015

Protected Classes

This isn't an opinion piece, just informational. Nothing to get excited about! 

Often you here the term "protected class" misused, even by people who should know better. You might hear a business owner shy away from disciplining a member of a racial minority because he (or she) is "in a protected class", as if minorities had rights and protections that the majority didn't have. You also hear this "protected class" language applied to women as well as religious minorities.

In United States Federal anti-discrimination law, a protected class is a characteristic of a person which cannot be used as a basis for discrimination. In other words, "class" does not refer to a group of people at all. An example of a characteristic might be "hair color". Every person has hair color (at least those who have hair!). If hair color was a protected class, it would be illegal to discriminate based on the color of someone's hair. 

One real example of a protected class is "race". Everyone has the characteristic of belonging to a certain race (setting aside for legal purposes the non-scientific basis and of race and it's perpetuation as a social contruct). Discrimination therefore is illegal if it is based on a person's race; not that people of certain race have special protections that members of other races do not have. The same goes for the other protected classes, some of which are: color, religion, national origin, age (over 40), gender, pregnancy, and citizenship status. 

When is it Okay to Refuse to Serve Someone Based on Your Religious Beliefs?

Is it okay for a religious person to refuse to bake a cake for a same-sex wedding if they object to same-sex marriage on religious grounds? If it's not, then is it okay for a person to refuse to bake a cake for a religious group that wants "God Hates Fags" written on the cake? I think that no matter which way you go, you're setting a bad precedent, because you can't write laws that favor one group or point of view over another. Because if you're going to compel a conservative religious person to bake a cake for a same-sex marriage, which they believe is a sin, then by the same legal logic you will have to force a gay, or gay-supportive, baker to make a cake that promotes an anti-gay message. It would be difficult to craft a law that makes it illegal for the religious person to deny service to whomever they choose while allowing non-religious people to similarly discriminate.

One argument that I hear fairly often is: "Why would I want to do business with someone who looks down on me?" Frankly, as a consumer, I should have that choice. I can decide that I don't want to do business with Barbie's Biblical Bakery if I hear that they take stands that I find abhorrent, but it's another thing altogether if I show up to order my cake and they decide not to serve me because of their religious beliefs. As a consumer, I should be able to go into any place of business and not be confronted by bigotry against my lifestyle, sexuality, religion (or lack of it), race or anything else. Now, I'm not talking about overt displays of religious belief. I have no problem with a Christian business indicating that they are a business run by Christians, even though there is a good chance that by advertising this, they believe that I am destined for Hell, as long as they keep their opinions to themselves and treat me as any other customer.

I don't know if this can be done legally, but here's what I think would be equitable: make it illegal to refuse to serve someone because they are gay, or refuse to supply a product or service because it will be used in a same-sex wedding. In other words, add "sexual orientation" as a protected class regarding discrimination. If a religious merchant who is against same-sex marriage on religious grounds is asked to participate in a same-sex marriage (e.g. officiant, deejay) or to produce messages (i.e. on a cake) that are clearly designed to offend, or that foment hatred, then they may demur. There have been some conservative Christian groups who have been targeting bakeries run by gays, asking them to bake cakes with anti-gay messages on them (some overt, some more subtle) - clearly being provocative. I have seen accusations that gay rights groups are targeting Christian bakeries in like manner, but haven't seen anything in legitimate media.

Since making this kind of discrimination illegal is either unlikely or will have unpleasant consequenses, let's not rule out the time-honored strategy of the boycott. A local bakery refused to do business with you because of their religious convictions? And it's not illegal? Fine; boycott the heck out of them; shame them on public media; picket their business. Make it plain that you (and anyone who joins you) find their practices to be morally and ethically wrong, despite their legality.

There is more than one way to fight injustice