Monday, March 31, 2014

Dad

On Tuesday February 25 I woke up to several text messages on my phone, which had been on silent mode overnight – my store has been instructed to call my landline after 10:00PM – one was from my brother Michael, which was unusual because we almost never call each other to chat, the other from my sister Patty. Both messages informed me that my father had experienced a stroke and was in the hospital. I was scheduled work go to work at 3:00PM, so I had plenty of time to digest this information and call my siblings. When I reached them they both told me, in no uncertain terms, that I should “come home”…now. Considering that this particular brother and this particular sister never agree on anything, I did not consider any other course of action other than going to New York.

After several hours of dealing with a series of un-empowered morons I booked my flight for the following morning. I arrived at the hospital at about 5:00PM Wednesday in a rental car after depleting my cell phone battery using the GPS directions function. All of my siblings, and eventually all but one of my father’s nieces and nephews and most of his grandchildren were on site. Dad was opening his eyes and appeared to be somewhat responsive to our presence, at one point meticulously rearranging his hair that one of us had absent-mindedly mussed up. At one point, as I sat at his side holding his hand and silently looking at him, he turned toward me and opened his eyes wide in what I interpreted as a sign of recognition. We all had those little moments. He seemed to be improving and we all held on to that little bit of hope.

On Thursday morning our hopes were proved to be wishful thinking.

It was soon evident that Dad would never fully recover, and any hope of even a partial recovery was at best a long shot. Conversations ensued and Mom informed the medical staff that Dad’s wishes, outlined in his living will, would be honored; no heroic measures. By Friday night Dad was transferred from Intensive Care to Hospice where we all gathered around be with him until the end.

Anyone who knew Dad knew that he had a crazy sense of humor, and was the source and subject of numerous hilarious stories. What I did not realize was the shear overwhelming number of funny incidents that he was a part of. We told stories for days, with hardly any repetition. There were many that I had never heard before, like when he was dozing on the subway on his way home from work and two thugs stole the hat right off his head. He was so angry, but everyone laughed about it, which made him madder! Or his set of “tools” that might have been brought over from Ireland in the 1800’s that Michael and my brother-in-law Scott jokingly argued about.

On Saturday night March 1st, after several of us went to watch my niece Bridy win a talent competition at her school, we gathered in his room, telling more stories, playing Bridy’s winning song and Dixieland music on Pandora. Eventually everyone headed home, I decided to stay behind, since I had not had an opportunity to be alone with him since I had arrived. I pulled up “Making a Snowball” on my cell phone and read it to him. If you've read it, you know it’s as much a tribute to Dad as it is a recounting of the waning days of my first marriage. I then talked to him, assuring him that Mom would be taken care of, and thanking him for all that he had done for me…for all of us. I encouraged him to let go and accept the ride to the other side.

Just before 8:00AM the next morning Dad indeed let go of the physical and embraced the eternal.

For as long as I can remember Dad was a man on a mission, dedicated to taking care of those whom he loved. Uncle Tim described him as a dutiful older brother. We all saw how dedicated he was to taking care of his mother, despite her many provocations, taking her shopping and calling her every day. He was devoted to Mom and took care of her in so many ways. He was a loving and protective father to the five of us, and even as adults he was always there for us. He was a great help at his church, setting up for mass, which he attended every morning. He was also there for his grandchildren, babysitting when they were younger. He was diligent about his finances, and our family never wanted for anything. He is now at rest.


Resting is how I picture him now. If there is an afterlife, which he surely believed in and I am leaning toward myself, he is taking advantage of it by simply taking a break. Sitting on the back porch of The Summerland of Irish myth with a Scotch or a beer or a cup of coffee looking out on us all; content in the knowledge that we’re all fine, and that we’ll be fine in large part due to what he instilled in us. 

Thursday, February 20, 2014

Is Historical Accuracy a Necessary Component of Religious Belief?

Is historical accuracy a necessary component of religious belief? Fundamentalist Christians and Muslims would certainly argue that it is. I would argue that the teachings of most religions that apply to everyday behavior, to relations among people and communities, do not bear an inseparable link to divine guidance. In fact, the rules of everyday behavior do not vary much from one religion to another. The so-called Golden Rule can be found in most faiths, and even outside them in secular teachings. Outside of the Sabbath and "Don't worship other gods", the Ten Commandments are pretty much  good common sense rules for how people should demonstrate basic respect for each other. Most of what is in the Koran, other than all the circular logic about how the Koran is revelation because God revealed it, and the conquer the infidels stuff, is good solid advice on how to be a responsible adult. Outside of those two Abrahamic faiths the stories of the gods and heroes are, as far as I know, not taken seriously as historical fact; the god and heroes may or may not have literally existed, but their historicity isn't the point, the lesson that the stories are telling is the point. But when we get to Christianity and Islam, somehow the literal, physical, verifiable, historical accuracy becomes the point. When so much weight is put upon the truth that Jesus or Mohammed existed, or that the Koran or Paul's epistles were divinely inspired, the emphasis switches from how one should act to what one should believe. If one takes the teachings in the Christian Gospels at face value, then it really makes no difference whether the Jesus mentioned therein was an historical figure, an invented character, a distortion based on a real person, or an amalgam of several different people, because the teachings in the Gospels stand or fall on their own logic and practicability, without reference to who promulgated them. One very common logical fallacy is appeal to authority - which is saying that just because "an authority" said it, then it must be true. Jesus, if the accounts are true, is the authority, he is the son of God, so what he says must be true, so any logic, or self-evident truth must now be subordinated to the reign of the authority. But if what is contained in a holy book is true, then what is said will still be true, no matter who said it and who wrote it down. Within Christian belief, where we run into problems is the doctrine, promulgated in the Pauline epistles, that it was Jesus' death, resurrection, ascension bodily into heaven and future return that is most important, pushing the moral and behavioral teachings off to the side and making belief more important than action. In fact, the idea that it is "faith alone", as opposed to "works" that is at the core of Protestantism, initially put forth by Martin Luther. Interestingly, several, if not many, pagan traditions have stories of sacrificed gods killed and reborn. None seem to try to connect these characters to real historical figures and place the importance on the lesson, rather than attempt to prove that they are "true".

So, I suppose the answer is that it depends on what your religious beliefs consists of. If your faith is built on an appeal to authority and on the quasi-magical attributes of a specific human or demi-god, then it matters a lot. But if one is focusing on morals, ethics, behavior, community and relations among people, then no, it matters not in the least.









Thursday, January 30, 2014

Using Religion to Justify Bigotry

While a rant against religion may be justified, that's not what I'm going to be doing this afternoon, rather ranting against those who use religion as an excuse for their bigotry and intolerance.

One of the big "headline" controversies these days is gay marriage. Many religious people resort to passages from their "holy" books to back up their view that gays are variously misguided sinners, poor souls apart from God or even abominations. Some even shake their head sadly, as if their bigotry wasn't their idea...they're just following God's instructions. Some are indignant that there are those who will criticize then for their bigotry, as if this criticism is infringing on their First Amendment rights of free speech and free exercise of religion. I'll start by looking at things from my own experience.

For many years I was part of a religious group that, among other things, preached that homosexuality was the most heinous of sins and that homosexuals were the "lowest of the low". This was interesting in that the initial teachings that you encountered with this group made a big point that there was no degrees of "badness" with sins: sin was sin. But somewhere along the line, preaching against homosexuality became a focus, even to the point of a purge of those who supposedly had "homosexual thoughts" or were, as the leader called them "homo sympathizers. Now, despite there being a  host of other non-biblical beliefs and behaviors that the leaders of this group classified as sin, homosexuality bore the brunt of their hatred and vitriol. The way that this translated down to the unwashed masses of this group seemed to depend on how homophobic they were to start off with. While I admit that I had swallowed the interpretation of the bible that condemned homosexuals and homosexuality during this time period, I had been friends with and associated with gays and lesbians before this became a major focus, and quickly repudiated this mindset after I left the group. Many people that I knew in the group seemed to take it to heart mucway too enthusiastically. From what I could see they had always had a revulsion against homosexuality, but now they had a divinely sponsored excuse to engage in their prejudice.

This doesn't mean that all religious people are like this. There are some, maybe even a majority, or at least a significant minority, who for one reason or another have not chosen to put their interpretation of the bible first and foremost - above common sense, reason, or even evidence to the contrary. These are people, absent anything that they heard in their churches, who would have no problem at all with their gay neighbors.

This rant is also not meant to suggest that homosexuality is the only area affected by this mindset or that Christians are the only people who practice this spiritually sanctioned idiocy. Look at the areas dominated by fundamentalist Islam. This part of the world is characterized by relegating women to, at best, second-class citizenship, or at worst, non-person-hood, without rights or recognition. Women in many of these regions are wrapped up in layers of cloth, sometimes with only their eyes visible, sometimes not even that, ostensibly to protect them from men who would be moved by lust if they happened to see any female flesh. In some situations, men who sexually assault a woman who is not dressed "modestly" are not at fault...the woman is. All of this in the name of some god.

While none of this would be reasonable under any circumstances, it would at least be consistent if the holy writings of these religions were unambiguously understood in the same way by all adherents. But as we all know, this isn't the case. Hard core religionists in both Christianity and Islam insist that the writings are plain and it is only the ungodly who come to conclusions and interpretations differently than they do. Those who come to different conclusions are not "real" Christians or "true" Muslims. No one really has a good answer to the question of why there are so many different interpretations, other than the damn things aren't as plain as the true believers think that they are.

Both the Bible and the Koran are claimed to be "inspired by God", which the fundamentalists in both religions understand to mean a word-for-word dictation by God to the writers. Much has been written about the origins of the Bible and the problems found therein, but there are just as many problems with the Koran, although most Muslim scholars are unwilling to question the myth of its origin. What many people do not know is that Mohammed, assuming that he existed in the fashion that Islamic history says he did, did not write down anything. He was apparently a combination religious-political-military leader, and it was only after his death that his successors sought to compile his sayings into one book. In the early days of Islam there were competing versions, until eventually all versions that did not have official sanction were burned.

So getting back to the competing versions of religious faiths, I believe that people gravitate toward versions of their religion that reflect what  they already believe, and mirror their pre-existing prejudices. For every scholar who insists that the Bible condemns homosexuality, another can make a perfectly good case that it does not. For every Muslim mullah who insists that women must be covered and prohibited from driving, another can make a perfectly good case that women should be treated as men's equals. So, with two interpretations of your holy book floating around, what would be the rationale for following the group that espouses the more hateful stance? In my view it's because the more hateful position "makes more sense" to you, because of your own predisposition to the hateful point of view.

You're not taking a principled stand against the ungodly and defending your religion from outside attack, you're using your version of religion to defend your myopic and unreasonable hatred.

Good luck with that










Sunday, November 10, 2013

Bespoke and Other Irritating Things

There are three things that have been irritating me lately: people who mindlessly re-post things on Facebook that are not true, people who post controversial things on Facebook and then either refuse to discuss their post or get offended that someone has a differing opinion, and third, the word "bespoke".

Let's start with the third: bespoke. There was a time when, if you wanted a suit (or anything else) made to your personal specifications, you'd say it was "custom", or "custom made" or made even "personalized" or "tailor made". "Bespoke" just sounds pretentious.

Now as to the other two, perhaps I shouldn't be too concerned about what shows up on Facebook and spend less time there, but the modes of interaction on Facebook are not somehow separate from "real" life, but are just one aspect of it.

One common aphorism that I disagree with is that you should not talk about religion or politics. I think that the reason most people believe this is that most people are too immature or opinionated to be able to have a respectful conversation with people with whom they disagree. This has always been true to a certain extent, but the instant "connectedness" of the internet has made it easier to insult those that are standing right in front of us. Why is it bad etiquette to have a discussion about comparative religious beliefs, to ask someone the reason for their beliefs? Why is it a a social faux pas to express an opinion about the current administration? Of course if your version of discussion and expression includes demonizing the other side of the political spectrum and belittling those who believe differently as heretics or mindless or "insert your favorite insult here" it would be socially awkward to have that discussion at Sally's birthday party. But surely two (or more) intelligent people can compare the pros and cons of any political issue without calling each other extreme and insulting names I've seen it done, I've done it myself. It's not that tough...if you respect the other person.

But in a weird kind of mirror universe way, people who would never utter a hateful, bigoted, opinionated word in the company of those who hold differing opinions think it's alright to post hateful, bigoted, opinionated words on Facebook where they are in virtual company with those who hold differing opinions. And then claim that they will not discuss, not debate, sometimes claiming that it's their page and telling others to back off. This is not isolated to some fringe group of Facebook users, but seems to be the prevailing culture. People want to trumpet their opinions, but don't want to be challenged, so what happens is people talk past each other. One person posts a meme about how squirrels are a menace to a free society, but those who love squirrels don't dare argue, but post their own memes in support of squirrels. No one listens to the other person, no one considers that there might be truth in the other's position, shots are just traded across the other's bows.

Add to this insularity is the propensity of many to just re-post something that backs up a pre-existing opinion, whether true or not. There is so much information available on the internet that it's pretty easy to determine whether something is factual or not, or at least to find out if there are differing points of view on a subject. One could spend all of one's time just debunking the crap that's easy to discredit, let alone the things that take a little time to research. And I'm not just talking about snopes.com, which some people mistakenly believe is bankrolled by some shadowy liberal cabal, but just some basic fact checking. It's frustrating.

This could all be fixed if I could just create a bespoke world.

Saturday, October 19, 2013

Music is Alive

The last time I was in an arena of any kind for a musical performance Jimmy Carter was the president. Granted, I had some good times attending concerts in those cavernous spaces designed, not for music, but for basketball and hockey, enjoying performances by the mega-acts of my youth. I much more prefer my music in small, intimate settings. As for my choice of musicians, I'd rather see a local or regional group than a national act any day. More often than not when I tell acquaintances about a band that I went to see I encounter blank stares. Dweezil Zappa, Return to Forever, Bela Fleck and the Flecktones, Chris Duarte, Tinsley Ellis, John Hiatt and Dave Alvin are all musicians that I have seen perform in recent years - I am astounded at how little their names are recognized. Now I still have affection for the bands of yesteryear, and some of the names I mentioned were popular in the past, but they are still thriving artists who are not just recycling their "hits", but still creating new material.

During a business trip with some colleagues we got to talking about music - several people complained about how they don't like it when a band they go to see plays "their new shit" instead of just sticking to the hits. Sad.

With so many artists of so many styles out there, why stick with the same old stuff all the time. Expand your musical horizons. Go to The Bourbon Theater, to The Zoo Bar; listen to KZUM; pick up Josh Hoyer's newest recording; fill your ears with some new stuff .

Music is alive, don't mummify it.

Thursday, September 26, 2013

Home

The bar top was a replica of (or perhaps not) of an old-style shuffleboard table, of the type that one upon a time inhabited the bars, pubs and taverns of America. At semi-regular intervals, abandoned newspapers, dinosaur-like in their non-digitalness, sprawled sadly, crying for attention and relevance. Dick Dale, who also cried for attention and relevance, shredded surf-redolent notes from the jukebox. State of the art flat screen televisions, a counterpoint to the many Post-it Notes™ and handwritten signs, lit the interior with a ghostly light. Home, or a reasonable facsimile thereof.
He sat at the bar, equidistant between the off-sale cooler, stacked high with beers-for-the masses, and the giant bag of popcorn which invited speculation about bacteria and mass-produced faux butter. It was close to empty, as it often was on a Thursday afternoon, populated only by the white guy who insisted that he was one quarter Cherokee (why is it that white people who claim Indian ancestry are always Cherokee?) and the guy in the waist-length black ponytail who announced at regular intervals that he was the illegitimate son of Anastasia Romanov. Regulars. At home. Like him.
Fairly easy it is to call a bar home when the usual definition doesn’t apply; after all, home is where you go when you’re done doing all the things that you have to do, where the day ends, where your stuff is. When you don’t have any stuff, when the day doesn’t ever really end, when it’s not just metaphorical, you enjoy your illusions wherever you can get ‘em. Especially when reality doesn’t quite measure up. And why should it? He knew that reality would kick in quite smartly at 2:00AM, when ready or not, it was time to leave his home and descend into the nightmare. Not exactly “livin’ the dream”.
What is madness? Some might say that it’s the recognition that the world isn’t what we want it to be…and it never will be. That it’s the railing against the unfairness of “the way things are” and the creation of a reality that fits our sense of right and wrong. That it’s a howling – knowing that “what’s real” will never, ever be the same as “what should be”. He knew madness, he knew the howling, he knew the emptiness.
Away from home, away from the nine-to-five, as the howling died down, reality was the back seat of an unheated car, wrapped in layers of goose-down and a woolen hat.


               
               

                

Thursday, September 12, 2013

Million Muslim March

The "Million Muslim March", to paraphrase Voltaire's description of the Holy Roman Empire, was neither Muslim, a march and was quite short of a million. While the central organizing group was indeed the American Muslim Political Action Committee (AMPAC), the planned march was a "Truther" event. A "Truther", for those who don't know, is one of a variety of people who believe that we have not been given "The Truth" about the events of September 11, 2001. The so-called Truth includes claims that the United States government or perhaps one of the intelligence agencies set the whole thing up, or maybe it was Israel. There are assertions that the planes crashing into the World Trade Center could not have caused them to collapse and that explosives must have been planted from within. Truthers generally believe that the government, or elements thereof, caused the events of 9-11 in order to justify the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan and to provide a pretext for curtailing civil liberties. Non-Muslim truther groups such as the DC Area 9/11 Truth Movement and Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth Movement were listed as partners in the event. Interestingly enough, AMPAC encourages it's followers to support Congressman Ron Paul and his son Senator Rand Paul. In addition to the Truther aspects of the Million Americans Against Fear (the new name for The Million Muslim March) - the event was to highlight the discrimination and targeting of Muslims by law enforcement that took place post 9-11 as well as the general discrimination by the public. 

So what was the big deal? A fringe group decides to stage their event on a significant day, yes a tragic day, in order to get attention. And get attention they did, despite their march turning into, as The Huffington Post called it, "A Few Hundred People Walking Down the Street". Without the outrage, and yes, the bigotry, that their event engendered, no one would have noticed them save the few tourists who happened to cross their path as they waited for the light to change. What was the big deal? If this had been a "Million Christian March", or if Glenn Beck had staged his event on 9/11/2010 instead of in late August, would there have been the anger, the anti-Muslim signs, the "patriotic" holding up traffic? 


And how about them bikers? How is riding around DC honoring the victims of 9-11, or the military or whoever they're supposed to be honoring? Sounds more like a visceral response to a group that they hate exercising their rights to free speech. Of course the somewhat-less-than-two-million bikers have the right as Americans to oppose a tiny-percentage-of-one-million Americans' exercise of their rights.

But just what are they protesting, these noble bikers? The message? I doubt they even know what it is. The fact that they're Muslims?

I guess in all of this I should be thankful that both groups got the opportunity to express their views.